Revista de Ciências Civis e Jurídicas

Abstrato

Criminal Justice and Constitutional Guarantees of Consensus of the Penal System in Brazil and the U.S.

Gordilho HJS and Williams K

This article is a comparative study between the criminal systems of Brazil and the US. Initially, examines the US system, which is founded on popular participation in the administration of justice and the consensual truth. The authors analyze the principles of due process and substantive due process of law from judicial interpretations of the US Supreme Court. This system has allowed the US 95% of criminal trails are resolved through negotiation between prosecution and defense, which makes the system faster, efficient and democratic, for allowing the accused to participate in the decision on the criminal sanction that will be reckoned. Finally, the author criticizes the Brazilian legislation, which from the 9099/95 Act introduced the consensual truth in the Brazilian criminal system to crimes punishable by up to two years in prison.